By Basant El-Faramawy
The Independent's editorial highlights a growing public rift between Chancellor John Healey and Prime Minister Andy Burnham over the prospect of the United Kingdom rejoining the European Union. The split emerged days after Burnham called for "honest discussions" on restoring freedom of movement, a core EU pillar and a condition for any future membership.
Public Split Over EU Rejoining
Burnham has repeatedly said he would like to see the UK back in the EU within his lifetime. Healey, who is ten years older, quipped that he does not expect to see that happen, noting that a man of his age can expect to live another 20 years, pushing any potential return to 2046. The editorial notes this is not the first time Healey has expressed a more sceptical view than his boss.
Economic Disagreement
Healey has denied that the UK would grow faster inside the EU or the single market, acknowledging Brexit has hit growth and trade but insisting the challenge is to make the best of the current economy. He has also appeared reluctant to join the "honest discussions" Burnham promoted.
Cabinet Discord
The editorial warns that a fundamental policy clash between the prime minister and chancellor historically leads to dysfunctional government. It also reveals that the home secretary was furious to learn from the media about Burnham's desire to restore freedom of movement, which would upend the post-Brexit points-based visa system and complicate immigration reforms.
Political Risks
Labour MPs in traditional "Red Wall" and Eurosceptic areas are suspicious of freedom of movement, fearing it will be weaponised by Reform and Conservative parties. The editorial argues that cabinet members owe the prime minister loyalty and collective responsibility, but urges Burnham to consult senior colleagues more carefully, especially ahead of his 10-year plan due in coming weeks.
Upcoming EU-UK Summit
Next month's EU-UK summit is cited as a success in repairing relations, with new arrangements on farming, energy, youth mobility, and defence. However, the editorial concludes that a more ambitious deal involving freedom of movement cannot be won unless the government and Labour Party are united, and that Burnham must first win the argument with his own chancellor and home secretary.
